Original Blog Post #3 - A Marketing Fall From Great Heights
Have you seen the new Wuthering Heights movie?
I haven't and I don't have any plans to. But I have seen a lot of people who have seen it talk about it. It's definitely one of the buzziest films of the year so far, and not all of that buzz has been positive.
The 2026 film directed by Emerald Fennell, Wuthering Heights, is an adaptation of the 1847 novel of the same name by Emily Brontë. I almost want to put quotations around the word adaptation, like the title is stylized on posters for the film, because it seems like calling it one is a stretch. Before the release of the movie and after, the film has come under fire from film critics, book lovers, and the public for it's questionable casting choices, disguised parallels to another controversial movie, and approach to adapting a beloved classic. Pre the release of the film on Valentine's Day, Wuthering Heights was facing criticism over it's choices to which the marketing of the film, including the press tour, did not address at all which furthered disappointed anyone on the fence about seeing the new take on it.Emerald Fennell wrote and directed the film. During the press tour she explained the reason for the quotation marks around the film's title on the poster in the video to Fandango below. She admits that its hard to "adapt" a book like the title's namesake and she has instead created a movie around what she remembers of reading the book as a teenager. While this is a very interesting concept to make into a movie, choosing to continue to still market the movie as a an adaptation without informing those, who maybe aren't following along on this press tour before seeing it, is false advertising. In the opinion of one commenter under this post, "I still feel like it would have been better if it was her original work, with an original name and she just acknowledged that she was greatly inspired by Wuthering Heights. So far, this seems so far removed from the source material, it's more like she's exploiting a popular brand without actually honouring the material."
Overall the movie may have marketed itself with big name actors and a promising director, but most of it's marketing was derived from angry fans outraged over many misleading and disrespectful choices. And it's not the first film in recent years that's done this. Remember the 2024 film adaptation It Ends With Us for the book with the same name by Colleen Hoover? A film that promises romance, with a hint at something more sinister in the trailer. Spoiler for those that haven't read the book or seen the movie, but the danger alluded to is the violent relationship the main character Lily Bloom is in with the films first partner, Ryle. However, this was not spoiled for a lot of people who went to see this movie for the chance at a love triangle when an old friend of Lily's comes back into her life, and many were shocked at the plot since it was not talked about a lot in the lead-up to the films release. Actress for Lily Bloom, Blake Lively, came under fire for promoting the film as typical romantic comedy and using the press tour to promote her hair care products instead of speaking out on the topics of domestic violence and emotional abuse that are huge themes in the show. What could have been a huge spotlight to spread awareness for victims and organizations that help survivors of both traumas was instead covered in flowery dresses.
Book to screen adaptations have the advantage of wide fanbases to tap into and gather excitement for upcoming films. Especially books that have been around for long periods of time. However, sometimes the people behind the film fumble this advantage hard with questionable marketing choices and disappoint new and old fans alike in theater. While it might still gather results, as Wuthering Heights did pull in $82 million in its global debut, it's reviews of 59% on Rotten Tomatoes and a 2.8 out of 5 on Letterboxd leave the conclusion of it's expectations to be desired.
Would you have changed anything about Wuthering Heights marketing?




You posed a difficult question to answer. Although the marketing wasn't true to what the movie actually was, it did get people's attention. At least, it got Wuthering Heights fans' attention. I haven't really heard anyone discussing this movie. That being said, I think it would've been better to have a separate name, inspired by the original. That way, people don't feel lied to or like the original work is being disrespected. In a way, it does feel like someone trying to monopolize on a popular story, although I doubt that is the intention based off of what the writers and directors said about it. I do love that it's what she remembered reading as a child. I think it would've been more successful if she marketed it like that, which would have tugged heartstrings.
ReplyDelete